Touted by some as the quickest player in the Central Coast Mariners squad, Buhagiar is born, raised and has spent the entirety of his football career on the Central Coast. Known for his pace as an attacking winger, Buhagiar is a product of the INTERNATIONAL FOOTBALL SCHOOL and signed his maiden Hyundai A-League contract during the 2016 January transfer window. Buhagiar is a Umina Eagles junior and has spent the off-season plying his trade with the Central Coast Mariners Academy.